(814) 362-9717

  • Home
  • Menu
  • Reservations
  • Events
  • Event Planning
  • Photo Gallery
  • More
    • Home
    • Menu
    • Reservations
    • Events
    • Event Planning
    • Photo Gallery

(814) 362-9717


  • Home
  • Menu
  • Reservations
  • Events
  • Event Planning
  • Photo Gallery

Our Menu

Homemade Soups

Soups

Vegetable Beef Soup

Cup 4.50 Bowl 5.50

Baked French Onion Soup

Crock 5.50

Soup of the Day

Cup 4.50 Bowl 5.50


Starters - Served All Day

Devils on Horseback

$11.50

Pieces of tender strip loin, wrapped in bacon, deep fried and tossed in hot sauce.

Flight of Dips

$11.95

Spinach and artichoke dip, chicken wing, taco, cheddar cheese,  and cheddar bacon ranch dip.

Choose 3 dips for $9.95

Mozzarella Sticks

$9.50

Strips of mozzarella cheese, lightly breaded and fried golden brown Served with homemade marinara sauce. 

Breaded Zucchini

$8.50

Zucchini lightly seasoned, breaded, and fried golden brown - served with marinara sauce.

Pizza Logs

$9.50

Pepperoni and mozzarella cheese lightly breaded and fried golden brown served with a side of marinara sauce.

Breaded Cauliflower

$8.50

Lightly breaded and fried cauliflower bites tossed in hot sauce served wit a side of blue cheese dressing.

Onion Petals

$8.50

Crispy battered onion petals served with a zesty boom boom sauce.

Stuffed Mushrooms

$9.25

A Beefeaters Specialty - Fresh mushroom caps (4) stuffed with our house seafood dressing Topped with sharp cheddar cheese .

Raspberry Chargrilled Shrimp

$11.00

Marinated and chargrilled shrimp served with a side of raspberry sauce.

Potato Skins

$10.50

Potato skins, loaded with cheese, bacon, and green onion. Served with sour cream and salsa.


Garden Salads - Served All Day

Salad Dressing Choices: Celery Seed, Blue Cheese, Ranch, Italian, Creamy Parmesan Peppercorn, Honey Mustard, French, Fat-Free Raspberry Vinaigrette, or Olive Oil & Balsamic Vinegar Add to Any Salad: Extra Salad Dressing $1.00 Blue Cheese Crumbles $1.00 French Fries $1.95

Tossed Green Side Salad

$4.45

Mixed greens with tomato, cucumber, radishes, garbanzo beans, & croutons 

Beefeaters’ Garden Salad

$9.95

Fresh tossed greens with tomato, cucumber, green peppers, radishes, garbanzo beans, hard-boiled egg, onion, cheddar cheese, and croutons 

Add: 6 oz Sliced Roast Beef, Grilled Chicken, Ham, Turkey, or Monte Cristo (Ham, Turkey, & Roast Beef) $4.00 

Grilled Strip Steak Salad

$18.95

7 oz sliced NY strip steak served on mixed greens, tomato, cucumber, green peppers, radishes, garbanzo beans, hard-boiled egg, onion, blue cheese crumbles, and croutons. 

Grilled Romaine Caesar Salad

$12.95

Half of a head of romaine lettuce is grilled, topped with melted blue cheese crumbles, chopped bacon, tomatoes, and Caesar dressing. 

Add: Grilled Chicken (6 oz) $4.00 

Grilled Shrimp (6) $8.00 

Strip Steak (7oz) $8.00

Salmon (8oz) $8.00


Beef Bar - Served All Day

* To achieve Rare and Medium Rare, the sliced beef will seem cool. If you would like it warmer, please ask for hot au jus or gravy on the side.

Roast Beef on Kummelweck

$11.75

Our famous “Beef on Weck” with tender sliced roast beef on a salted kummelweck bun Add Up to 2 Sides: $1.95 each

Roast Beef Dinner

$17.75

Tender roast beef under thick gravy or au jus Served with choice of potato, tossed salad, warm rolls and butter.

Traditional Hot Roast Beef Sandwich

$13.75

Tender sliced roast beef between two pieces of our homemade bread, covered with thick gravy; Served with choice of side 

French Dip Sandwich

$12.95

Freshly cooked, thinly slice roast beef served on a fresh roll with a side of au jus. 


Burgers

Add a description about this category

Build Your Own Burger - Served All Day

$17.95

Served with French Fries. Choice of: Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Pickle, Mayo, Ketchup, Mustard Add Any of These Toppings for $1.00 each: Bacon, Sautéed Mushrooms, Sautéed Onions, Cheese (American, Provolone, Swiss, Pepper jack, Mozzarella, Cheddar, BC Crumbles) 


Lunch Sandwiches - Served Tues-Fri 11am-4pm

Each Sandwich comes with a choice of a complimentary side.

Deli Sandwiches

$10.95

Your choice of turkey, ham, cold roast beef, or tuna served on choice of bread.

Turkey Melt

$10.95

Sliced smoked turkey breast between swiss and American cheese grilled on rye bread.

Grilled Reuben

$10.95

Sliced corn beef, swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and thousand Island dressing.

Rachel

$10.95

Sliced, smoked turkey breast, coleslaw, thousand island dressing and swiss cheese grilled on rye bread.

BLT

$8.95

Crispy bacon, lettuce, and tomato served on white bread

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

$10.95

Chargrilled chicken breast with lettuce, tomato, onion, and mayo served on a toasted Kaiser roll.

Shrimp Po Boy

$12.95

Crispy, crunchy shrimp piled on a buttery toasted French roll, stuffed with coleslaw, topped with tomatoes and drizzled with sriracha.

Grilled Cheese Sandwich

$8.95

Warm, melted American cheese sandwiched between white bread and toasted to perfection.

Chicken Parmesan Sandwich

$10.95

Tender hand breaded chicken breasts deep fried then baked with marinara sauce, mozzarella, and provolone cheese served on a kaiser roll


Hot Lunch Favorites - Served Tues - Fri 11am-4pm

Add a description about this category

Hand Carved Turkey

$14.95

 Roasted turkey breast and mashed potatoes topped with gravy and served with a side of our vegetable of the day .

Cajun Chicken Alfredo

$11.95

Chargrilled Cajun chicken served on a bed of fettuccine noddle's topped with rich, parmesan cream sauce. Served with tossed green salad and garlic bread

Spaghetti

$12.95

 Pasta topped with marinara sauce Add: Homemade Meatballs (2) $2.95          Sautéed Mushrooms $2.75 

Salisbury Steak

$14.95

 (2) 4oz Salisbury steaks; served over mashed potatoes smothered in a mushroom marsala sauce with a side of our vegetable of the day. 

Broiled Icelandic Haddock

$16.95

Add a description about this item

Beef Stroganoff

$13.95

Tender chunks of beef with a creamy brown mushroom sauce served over noodles. comes with house vegetable salad and roll.

Lasagna

$16.95

Housemade lasagna prepared with layers of pasta, parmesan cheese , mozzarella cheese, assorted cheeses, and our meat sauce.  


Dinner Entrées - Served Mon- Fri 4pm-9pm & Sat 11am-9pm

All dinners include tossed green salad, choice of potato (unless stated otherwise), and warm rolls.

Lobster Tail

(1 Tail) Market Price (2 Tails) Market Price

Served with drawn butter

Balsamic Glazed Salmon

$22.95

8oz Salmon filet topped with a balsamic glaze served over a bed of rice.

Stuffed Haddock Au Gratin

$17.95

Icelandic haddock stuffed with our special seafood stuffing. Topped with cheddar cheese.

Broiled Icelandic Haddock

$16.95

Choice of: Lemon Pepper, Cajun or Scampi

Raspberry Chargrilled Chicken Breast

$17.95

Fresh chicken breast marinated in our house seasoning, chargrilled and topped with our raspberry sauce (8 oz)

Creamy Chicken Piccata

$19.95

Lightly breaded chicken filets on a bed of smothered pasta with lemon, cream and white wine sauce with spinach, mushrooms and capers. 

Lasagna

$16.95

Housemade lasagna prepared with layers of pasta, parmesan cheese , mozzarella cheese, assorted cheeses, and our meat sauce. 

Chicken Parmesan With Pasta

$17.95

(2) Hand-breaded chicken breasts, deep fried then baked with marinara sauce, mozzarella, and provolone cheeses on top of a bed of pasta.

Salisbury Steak

$14.95

 (2) 4oz Salisbury steaks; served over mashed potatoes smothered in a mushroom marsala sauce with a side of our vegetable of the day.

Hand Carved Turkey

$14.95

Roasted turkey breast and mashed potatoes topped with gravy and served with a side of our vegetable of the day 

Fettuccine Broccoli Alfredo

$16.95

Fettuccine noodles topped with a rich, Parmesan cream sauce and tender broccoli 

Add: Grilled Chicken $4.00

         Shrimp (6) $8.00

Spaghetti

$12.95

Pasta topped with marinara sauce 

Add: Homemade Meatballs (2) $3.95 

         Sautéed Mushrooms $2.75 

Butternut Squash Ravioli

$16.95

Butternut squash raviolis in a brown butter and sage sauce topped with candied pecans served with a side, salad and roll.

Beef Stroganoff

$14.95

Tender chunks of beef with a creamy brown mushroom sauce served over noodle. served with a house vegetable, salad, and roll.


Steak Dinners - Served Mon - Fri 4pm-9pm Sat 11am-9pm

Steak entrées include a choice of side, tossed green salad, warm rolls, and butter

Prime Rib of Beef Au Jus

Queen 29.95 King 33.95 Super 38.95

Perfectly seasoned and roasted slowly to lock in all the natural flavors.

Queen (14 oz)  King(18 oz)  

Super (24 oz)  

Beefeaters Surf and Turf

$29.95

10oz grilled Strip Steak & 4 chargrilled jumbo gulf shrimp.

 Only available cooked medium and above.

Filet Mignon

$31.95

Hand cut 6oz filet cooked to your specification. 

Rack of Lamb

$36.95

Chargrilled with our house seasoning Served on a bed of mashed potatoes with a side of mint jelly 

New York Strip Steak

$28.95

 Hand cut 12 ounces of strip steak. 

Prime Rib and Steak Additions

Surf & Turf: Lobster Tail (8 oz) Add  Market Price

Jumbo Chargrilled Shrimp (6) Add $8.95 

Smothered (Sautéed Mushrooms, Onions, Melted Blue Cheese Crumbles) Add $4.95 

Fresh Sautéed Mushrooms Add $2.45 

Fresh Sautéed Onions Add $1.95 

Melted Bleu Cheese Crumbles Add $2.45


Kids Menu

Children’s entrées include a drink, choice of side, and ice cream. Sides: fries, mashed potatoes, or apple sauce.

Chicken Fingers

$7.95

served with a side of ranch dressing 

Grilled Cheese

$6.25

Hot Dog

$6.25

Spaghetti and Meatball

$7.50

served with garlic bread (no choice of side) 

Pizza Logs

$7.50

served with a side of marinara sauce

Kraft® Macaroni and Cheese

$6.95

Peanut Butter & Jelly

$6.25

Mozzarella Sticks

$7.50

Served with marinara sauce


Sides $3.25

Hot German Potato Salad 

Coleslaw 

French Fries 

French Fries with Gravy 

Pasta Salad 

Mashed Potatoes 

Baked Potato  

Baked Beans 

Vegetable of the Day 


Beverages

$2.95

Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Ginger Ale, Raspberry Iced Tea, Pink Lemonade, Root Beer, Sierra Mist, Mountain Dew, Fresh Brewed Iced Tea, Milk, Hot Chocolate, Coffee (Regular & Decaf)  


Desserts

$4.95

Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup 

Apple Crumb Pie

Fudge Brownie Delight 

Tin Roof Sundae 

Strawberry Shortcake

Chocolate Sundae 

Crème Brulee




Beer & Wine Selections

Beer - Ask Us About Draft & Seasonal Selections

Budweiser, Bud Light, Coors Light, Miller High Life, Miller Lite, Michelob Light, Michelob Ultra, Samuel Adams, Yuengling, Blue Moon, Landshark, Molson Canadian, Labatt Blue, Labatt Blue Light, Labatt Blue NA (Non-Alcoholic), Corona Extra, Heineken, Guinness, Stella Artois, Angry Orchard Hard Cidar.

Local Brews

Southern Tier IPA, Ellicottville Brewing Company Blueberry Wheat, Straub Amber

Champagne

Dom Pérignon (France)

Bottle  225.00


House Champagne

Bottle  24.95

Sparkling Wines

Ask your server about our current selections.

House Red Wines

Lambrusco, Merlot, Cabernet Sauvignon, Shiraz Cabernet, Pinot Noir, Hazlitt Red Cat

Glass  5.50  •  Half Carafe  15.00  •  Full Carafe  31.00


House Blush Wine

White Zinfandel

Glass  5.50  •  Half Carafe  15.00  •  Full Carafe  31.00


Red Wines by the Glass or Bottle

Zinfandel - Gnarly Head (California)

Bottle  24.95      


Cabernet Sauvignon - Francis Coppola Black Label Claret (California)

Glass  8.00  •  Bottle  31.95


Cabernet Sauvignon - Beringer Founders’ Estate (California)

Bottle  24.95 


Pinot Noir - Mark West (California)

Bottle  29.95     


Merlot - Kendall Jackson Vinter's Reserve (California)

Bottle  31.95

House White Wines

Chardonnay, Riesling, Pinot Grigio, Moscato

Glass  5.50  •  Half Carafe  15.00  •  Full Carafe  31.00


White Wines by the Glass, Bottle, or Carafe

Pinot Grigio - DaVinci (Italy)

Glass  8.50  •  Bottle  32.95  


Sauvignon Blanc - Yellow Tail (Australia)

Glass  6.75  •  Half Carafe   17.00  •  Full Carafe  35.00


Chardonnay - Kendall Jackson (California)

Glass  8.75  •  Bottle  32.95


Riesling - Chateau St. Michelle (Washington)

Bottle  24.95


Consuming raw or undercooked meats, especially ground meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, fish, or eggs may increase your risk for foodborne illness. 🔸 - this symbol denotes gluten-free offerings. 🌱 - this symbol denotes vegetarian offerings. For those with food allergies, please inform us before placing your order. Our menu items may contain wheat, egg, dairy, soy, fish, or other allergens.

Copyright © 2025 Beefeaters at the Historic Carnegie Library - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by